Search News & Press Releases

New Report from NJSBA Pandemic Task Force Committee on the Resumption of Jury Trials Explores Issues, Makes Recommendations

November 17, 2020
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Kate Coscarelli
732-937-7548
   
New Report from NJSBA Pandemic Task Force Committee on the Resumption of Jury Trials Explores Issues, Makes Recommendations
   
Virtual civil trials should be voluntary to start, with central goal to ensure transparent, deliberative process that bolsters public confidence  
     
With civil jury trials on hiatus due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the New Jersey State Bar Association understands the importance of moving forward with civil jury trials to resolve matters for members of the public and businesses that have spent the past seven months in a holding pattern. At the invitation of the Judiciary, the Association’s Pandemic Task Force Committee on the Resumption of Jury Trials provided a series of recommendations, formed after researching options taking place around the country, that would accommodate civil jury trials in a virtual environment while ensuring that those trials are fair, just and produce a credible result.   
    
The Committee, composed of civil trial attorneys, criminal defense attorneys, county prosecutors and retired members of the Judiciary, sent its report to the Judiciary this month. It has previously released several reports and analysis on jury selection and the hybrid criminal jury trials that have been held in recent weeks.   
     
At its core, the NJSBA proposes an initial statewide, voluntary pilot program for virtual civil jury trials that will allow all parties involved in the judicial process to move forward with deliberate resolve and transparency to maintain the public’s confidence in the courts. The pilot project is intended to allow for the flexibility to make adjustments, when needed, before a more robust rollout of a virtual civil trial program. In producing its recommendations, one of the main goals of the Committee was to ensure that the same rules and procedures in place for in-person proceedings are maintained.   
     
“The NJSBA appreciates the opportunity to provide meaningful input as the pandemic requires us all to pivot in ways unimagined before to ensure that our judicial system can continue to move forward,” the report states. “We do not believe a virtual jury trial system should be mandated until all of the participants have an informed understanding about how a virtual trial will be conducted, and until some trials have actually happened on a voluntary basis. While lawyers and judges may participate in many jury trials in a given year, for most litigants their jury trial represents their one and final chance to resolve their dispute. It is critical that their ‘day in court’ be conducted under the best circumstances we can provide, with all necessary safeguards in place to ensure the rights of all parties are adequately protected and all opportunities available to present the best case possible.”   
     
The report examines a number of issues, including: how jurors will be chosen; how the Court will ensure that jurors attentively participate; how evidence will be presented – live or recorded; and how a jury will be expected to securely and privately deliberate to ensure a credible result that bolsters public confidence that a fair and meaningful resolution to disputes can be reached. In addition to those considerations, the Committee recommends the Courts conduct a robust survey following trials jurors in order to gather feedback with the aim of using it to improve the process in a way that allows the Judiciary to consistently and efficiently administer a fair trial.  
     
Here are key recommendations contained in the report:   
     
Jury selection: Virtual jury trials will only be successful if the parties are assured a panel of impartial jurors. This cannot be accomplished if traditional procedural protections are reduced or eliminated.
     
• Counsel must be present and involved during all stages of jury selection;   
• There must be no change to the number of peremptory challenges or the overall number of deliberating jurors; and   
• There must be a searching inquiry of all jurors for potential bias.
     
Presentation of Evidence: The Committee expressed an overarching concern about ensuring cases would be heard by a representative jury of the community that was not encumbered by the availability of technology and that there ought to be a standardization of platforms and training to ensure litigants stand on equal footing in their ability to present evidence. Some of the additional recommendations include:
      
• Every trial participant should have the same or an otherwise neutral virtual background;  
• Parties should receive step-by-step instructions for viewing evidence;  
• Judges should have two monitors; attorneys should try to have two monitors;  
• A technical assistant should hold trainings with the jury prior to proceedings;  
• Counsel should be allowed to agree on evidence presentation administered by a third-party vendor;  
• Witnesses should be placed in virtual waiting rooms;  
• Documents should be locked and files submitted in specific formats;  
• Sidebars should be held in virtual breakout rooms; and   
• Jurors should not be able to use chat functions.  
   
Survey: The NJSBA believes that a robust survey is needed following any virtual trials. It will be critical in developing a process that allows the Judiciary to consistently and efficiently administer a fair trial.
       
• The survey should target methods of presenting information so that attorneys and the Court can gain valuable feedback on the manner in which jurors prefer to receive information in a virtual trial setting.    
   
The NJSBA vowed to continue to be an active partner with the legal community and Judiciary to find a path forward.   
   
“We commend the Judiciary and the legal community for all that has been accomplished virtually up to this point. Calendar calls, motions, detention hearings and settlement conferences have all evolved. Further, we appreciate the extent to which many of the suggestions we have offered to date have been incorporated to best benefit the public and those of us entrusted with the responsibility to advocate on the public’s behalf. We have all learned many lessons since we were thrust into this new pandemic era last March… We will continue gathering information in the days ahead and expect to submit additional suggestions to the Judiciary.”
     
Read the full report and see the other reports of the Pandemic Task Force, including its reports on virtual criminal trials and law firm reopening issues at njsba.com. 
Committee on the Resumption of Jury Trials Members
   
William H. Mergner Jr., chair
Craig M. Aronow
Hon. Dennis F. Carey III, P.J.Cv. (Ret.)
Bina Desai
Michael G. Donahue
Kathleen Barnett Einhorn
Hon. Bradley Ferencz (Ret.)
Hon. Kenneth J. Grispin (Ret.)
Robert B. Hille
Reema S. Kareer
Brandon D. Minde
Brian J. Neary
Christopher M. Placitella

Contact: NJSBA Communications Department
Tel: 732-937-7527
Email: [email protected]

About


Founded in 1899, the NJSBA is the largest organization of attorneys, judges and legal professionals in New Jersey. At the core of our mission is improving the lives of our members, advancing the rule of law and serving as the voice of the profession. With 85 sections and committees, the NJSBA allows attorneys to benefit from being part of the most wide-reaching legal association in the state, while still cultivating expertise and building networks within specialized practice areas.

MORE ABOUT NJSBA

Diversity


The New Jersey State Bar Association is committed to promoting and fostering a diverse and inclusive bar association. The Association recognizes that the broad concept of diversity includes race, ethnicity, gender, gender identity, sexual orientation, religion, age and disability. The NJSBA fosters and promotes an inclusive environment that gives value to the unique contributions of diverse individuals and organizations in all aspects of the Association.

Learn More

Advocacy


The NJSBA Legal and  Government Affairs Department serves as the liaison between NJSBA members and the state’s three branches of government.

Directions

The New Jersey Law Center is located at 1 Constitution Sq, New Brunswick, NJ, 08901. Need directions to the Law Center? Click on the button below to get started right away.

Contact NJSBA

NJSBA Contact Us Form
If you're looking for an attorney, click here for help.

If you cannot afford an attorney and have a civil matter, click here for Legal Services of New Jersey.

Looking for information about a specific lawyer? Contact the Lawyer’s Fund for Client Protection at 855-533-3863.

Have a complaint about a lawyer? Visit the Office of Attorney Ethics website. Select “Attorney Discipline” from the navigation bar for discipline of attorneys.

Contact Info

One Constitution Square
New Brunswick, NJ 08901

732-249-5000
9 a.m. to 5 p.m., Monday - Friday

Fax 732-249-2815

Email us

NJSBA Meetings and Events Calendar


From section, committee and division meetings with valuable CLE credit, to receptions and dinners and special events, the New Jersey State Bar Association regularly holds meetings so our members can meet their mandatory CLE requirements and network with the state’s largest attorney membership.

View Calendar

2024 Annual Meeting & Convention


The New Jersey State Bar Association is thrilled to announce the 2024 Annual Meeting & Convention will be held at the Borgata Hotel, Casino & Spa May 15-17

For more information, or to register today, visit the links below:

View more information

2024 Mid-Year Meeting


The New Jersey State Bar Association is thrilled to announce the 2024 Mid-Year Meeting will be held at The Shelbourne Hotel, Nov. 2-9

For more information, or to register today, visit the links below:

View more information

Practice HQ Training Events


Lawyers aren't taught practice management skills, and the NJSBA is here to fill the gap — no matter whether you are just starting out, mid-career or thinking about wrapping up their practices. Our PracitceHQ is here to help with webinars, informative articles, free consultations, comparison charts and so much more.

Practice HQ Training Events

Decisis


The new NJSBA member benefit Decisis will help you level-up your legal research.

Decisis gives members access to a robust database of local and federal case law is necessary information often used to structure your case. Decisis provides industry-leading tools to make legal research easier and more intuitive, and it’s a free benefit to all active New Jersey State Bar Association members.

Decisis Training Events

Networking Events


The NJSBA provides a host of networking events so members can maintain relationships with existing colleagues and make new connects. Join us at a baseball game, the hockey arena, for a community service project, or another event.

Upcoming Networking Events

Benefits Of Membership


As a member of the New Jersey State Bar Association (NJSBA), you will join a powerful network of 16,000 legal professionals across the state of New Jersey. NJSBA membership grants you access to year-round virtual and in-person networking events, leadership and professional development opportunities, member-only discounts, educational resources to help you stay in the know and much more!

Practice Management Tools


The NJSBA provides tools lawyers need to improve their practice, from our comprehensive PracticeHQ library of resources; a career center to find your next colleague or opportunity; an intuitive and high-powered legal research platform; and a robust Member Assistance Program to connect members, and those who live in their households, with experienced counselors and resources to address mental health needs.

 

Advocacy


As an NJSBA member, you'll become part of the collective power of the NJSBA network, giving you the ability to influence legislation and caselaw in New Jersey. Let’s work together to shape the future and solve critical issues facing attorneys and the public.

Become a Member Today!

Networking


Membership helps you build and maintain a powerful network through our in-person and online events with attorneys all over the state.

 

Become a Member Today!

Become A Partner Organization


The New Jersey State Bar Association (NJSBA) offers an exclusive partnership opportunity to amplify your organization’s impact and drive success. By harnessing the power of the NJSBA legal community, you can connect with our vibrant network of 16,000 legal professionals from 35+ different areas of practice, unlocking unparalleled opportunities for growth and achievement.

 

News and Press Publications


Learn more about the accomplishments of the Association, its members and events from regular news updates, press releases, and our award-winning magazine.


 

Reports


Read the comments, reports, resolutions and Board of Trustee news from the state’s largest organization of lawyers, judges and legal professionals.


 

Statements and Positions


The NJSBA is the voice of the profession and takes public positions on a range of issues with the legal community and government officials. It also takes positions on legislation and files friend-of-the-court briefs on matters that impact the profession. 

Photo Galleries


Check out photos from recent NJSBA events.

View Photo Albums

You do not have permission to view this form.